Lymphocyte apoptosis and its association with the inflammatory markers and disease severity in juvenile-onset systemic lupus erythematosus patients

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is a systemic autoimmune disease with multiple immune dysregulation mechanisms. Juvenile-onset systemic lupus erythematosus (jSLE) represents a complex and multifactorial autoimmune disorder that predominantly affects children and adolescents, presenting distinct clinical and immunological challenges when compared to its adult-onset counterpart. It differs from adult-onset SLE (aSLE) in its higher disease activity, increased damage at an earlier stage and the need for use of immunosuppressive drugs at more frequent pattern [1]. The etiology of jSLE remains enigmatic, with the interplay of genetic predisposition, hormonal factors, and aberrant immune responses contributing to its pathogenesis. Among the intricate facets of jSLE pathophysiology, dysregulated lymphocyte apoptosis has emerged as a compelling central mechanism in recent years [2].

Lymphocyte apoptosis, a fundamental process of programmed cell death, plays a pivotal role in maintaining immune homeostasis by orchestrating the elimination of autoreactive and senescent lymphocytes, as well as the proper clearance of apoptotic bodies [3, 4]. In jSLE, the delicate balance between apoptosis and cell survival mechanisms, along with the defective clearance of apoptotic bodies, appears to be disrupted. This disruption potentially leads to the persistence of autoreactive lymphocytes and the perpetuation of the autoimmune response. Together, these factors contribute to the disturbance in lymphocyte apoptosis and show potential as key determinants in the clinical course and severity of jSLE [2, 5, 6].

Moreover, mounting evidence suggests that dysregulated lymphocyte apoptosis in jSLE may be closely connected with the pro-inflammatory milieu orchestrated by cytokines [7]. Inflammatory cytokines, including interleukin-17 (IL-17) [8, 9], interferon-gamma (IFN-γ) [10, 11], and tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-α) [12‐14], have been implicated as pivotal players in jSLE pathogenesis, contributing to tissue damage and immune dysregulation. The intricate crosstalk between aberrant lymphocyte apoptosis and these inflammatory mediators presents a compelling point for further exploration.

Identification of the molecular processes responsible for leukocyte apoptosis has gained significant consideration [15, 16]. Indeed, numerous research groups have linked various signaling pathway products, such as FasL, NF-κB [17], and Bcl-2 [18], to impaired apoptosis. This potential connection may ultimately contribute to hyperactivity of B and T lymphocytes resulting in excessive accumulation of autoantigens, polyclonal B cell activation and increases in autoantibody production [19, 20].

Lymphocytes themselves have a significant role in controlling the apoptosis of different cell types. For instance, cytotoxic T cells release enzymes like perforin and granzyme B, which can induce apoptosis in target cells. Additionally, T lymphocytes produce Fas ligand (FasL/CD95L), which interacts with Fas (Apo-1/CD95) on epithelial cells, leading to their apoptosis [20].

Unfortunately, the current understanding of immunopathological mechanisms and treatment protocols for jSLE is primarily derived from studies conducted on aSLE patients. This study is dedicated to unraveling the age-specific immunopathogenesis in jSLE and confirming whether it aligns with findings observed in aSLE patients, thereby addressing previous recommendations on this matter [1].

We evaluated the role of peripheral blood (PB) lymphocyte apoptosis in prognosis of jSLE and as a predictor for disease activity. The levels of apoptotic lymphocytes (AL) in PB of jSLE patients was compared to healthy controls. Also, we determined plasma levels of the pro-inflammatory cytokines in jSLE patients in comparison to healthy controls. We correlated PB lymphocyte apoptosis with the clinical manifestations, disease activity and inflammatory markers in jSLE patients.

SLE is a systemic autoimmune disease whose pathogenesis implicates many immune mechanisms, interplaying in a rather complex way that has not been fully elucidated yet. The presence of autoantibodies is the hallmark of ‘classical’ SLE that are mainly directed toward nuclear antigens and autoreactive lymphocytes. This applies to most cases of jSLE except those with early onset disease that starts before 5 years of age [2]. The immunopathogenesis is even more complex in jSLE where genetic and hormonal factors contribute more centrally in the pathophysiology [1]. The release of autoantibodies was constantly suggested to be a result from the increase in lymphocyte apoptosis and failure of macrophage clearance of apoptotic cells [6].

This study aimed to evaluate the role of peripheral blood lymphocyte apoptosis in the prognosis of jSLE and as a predictor for disease activity as previously validated and demonstrated for aSLE [6, 23‐30]. We also aimed to correlate percentage of AL with pro-inflammatory cytokines and clinical features to eventually reach age-specific laboratory findings elaborating immunopathological mechanisms characteristic for this age group upon which targeted treatment protocols and disease prognosis could address. We found that percentages of AL in jSLE patients were significantly higher than those of healthy controls and they were also significantly positively correlated with disease activity represented as SLEDAI-2 K. In addition, Active group of jSLE patients have significantly higher percentages of PB lymphocyte apoptosis than those of the inactive group. These results resemble findings observed in aSLE in both aspects; increased percentage of AL and their correlation to disease activity [6, 27]. However, other studies that were performed in aSLE showed significance only in the increased AL in aSLE patients while the correlation between their count and disease activity was not significant [28, 30].

The plasma levels of inflammatory cytokines (IL-17, IFN-γ and TNF-α) were significantly higher in jSLE patients in comparison to healthy controls. Similarly, previous observations have shown that IL-17 levels were significantly higher both in jSLE [31‐34] and aSLE [35, 36] strongly suggesting its potential as a therapeutic target [37, 38]. Regarding IFN-γ and TNF-α, studies that were performed in pediatric and adolescent patients investigating their role in jSLE have focused on their gene expression levels and polymorphisms rather than their serum or plasma levels; reporting their overexpression in jSLE and correlation with disease activity and clinical manifestations [34]. Polymorphisms in TNF-α was also reported to influence susceptibility to jSLE [39]. Postal et al. found that serum levels of TNF-α was significantly higher in jSLE patients than controls, while serum levels of IFN-γ showed no significant difference. On the other hand, Cavalcanti et al. reported that they did not find significant difference in levels of IL-17, IFN-γ or TNF-α in jSLE [40]. We postulate, considering the smaller sample size included in the latter two studies, that significant differences may have appeared with larger representative samples. This controversy seen in studies done in jSLE patients investigating previous cytokines is not present in those performed in aSLE in which the significant increase in levels of IL-17, IFN-γ or TNF-α has been widely recognized for a considerable time [8, 10‐12, 41, 42].

IL-17, IFN-γ and TNF-α are proinflammatory cytokines that are mainly secreted by T helper lymphocytes along with other innate and adaptive immune cells. TNF-α is also primarily secreted by activated macrophages [13], which contribute also to a lesser extent in the production of IFN-γ. IL-17 is specifically produced by Th17 cells derived from naive T cells under the effect of different combinations of other cytokines like TGF-β with IL-21 [43],or IL-6, IL-23, IL-1β and TNF-α [44]. A large fraction of the IL-17 found in SLE patients originates from CD4⁻CD8⁻ double-negative (DN) T cells which also produces IFN-γ. These cells are infrequent in healthy individuals; however, they were found abundantly in PB of SLE patients [45]. IL-17 and IFN-γ impact SLE by modulating autoantibody production through acting directly on B cells [36], or indirectly through recruiting inflammatory cells and stimulating of macrophages, synoviocytes, fibroblasts and neutrophils [37, 46]. Stimulated macrophages and activated T cells produce TNF-α which is known to be a potent apoptotic inducer [13, 14]. The increase in apoptotic cells cause subsequent increase in autoantigen load which indirectly increase autoantibodies [27]. Our findings, which show a positive correlation between plasma levels of IL-17 and IFN-γ and the percentages of AL in peripheral PB of jSLE patients, align with the previous explanations of immunopathogenesis. This provides affirmation for investigating these factors in the specific context of jSLE. Although no significant association was found between the levels of TNF-α and the percentages of AL, its concurrent significant elevation in jSLE patients, along with IFN-γ, rules out the presence of an intrinsic defect in macrophage function as a possible cause for the defective clearance of apoptotic bodies. In accordance with this finding, a prior study has shown that lower ability of macrophage to phagocytose apoptotic bodies was secondary to serum factors rather than a primary defect in macrophages [27]. Complement deficiency was suggested to be among these factors [47]. Notably, hypocomplementemia was observed in fifty percent of our patients.

The main limitations of this study involve the limited number of individuals in each group. Furthermore, the drugs used by patients might have affected the percentages of lymphocyte apoptosis. However, studying the correlation between percentages of lymphocyte apoptosis and disease activity is highly important in exploring their role in the prognosis of lupus.

To the best of our knowledge, this is the first in vivo case control study that investigated the role of AL in jSLE in practical means that provide age-specific relevance for its prognostic performance in terms of evaluating its significance in differentiating active from inactive disease and furthermore, correlating with other inflammatory cytokines which showed evidence that can prove theory implicating defective macrophage clearance in immunopathogenesis. Further studies are needed to elucidate the sequence of events revealed in the results regarding the interplay between AL and inflammatory cytokines. These studies should determine whether AL is a consequence of systemic inflammation or if it acts as the driving force behind such events, possibly influenced by other serum factors. Identifying the trigger for these events should be the focus of future research aimed at exploring potential therapeutic solutions.