Genetics of chronic nonbacterial osteomyelitis in the irish population: no significant association with rare FBLIM1 variants

Dear Sir,

We read with interest the recent article by d’Adamo et al. demonstrating a high prevalence of rare FBLIM1 gene variants in an Italian cohort with CNO [1]. This showed 22 % of 80 patients with CNO carried at least one rare variant in FBLIM1 with a gnomAD global minor allele frequency (MAF) less than 0.02. The FBLIM1 gene was first implicated in the pathogenesis of CNO by Cox et al. who identified rare variants in 2 patients of South East Asian descent, one of whom had consanguineous parents resulting in a recessively inherited form of the disease [2]. In addition, there was statistically significant enrichment of a nonsynonymous missense variant rs114077715 (p.Gly311Arg) in a European-American population with CNO [2]. These findings in the context of Fblim1 expression of in the cmo murine model suggested a role either for these FBLIM1 variants or a variant in close linkage disequilibrium to them in the pathogenesis of CNO. In the Italian cohort, the MAF of rs114077715 was 0.013, which was not significantly enriched compared to the gnomAD global MAF of 0.019 (odds ratio 0.64, p = 0.77). The MAF of the synonymous variant rs140170023 was 0.063, which was statistically significantly enriched compared to the gnomAD global allele count of 2993/253,068 or MAF of 0.012 (odds ratio 5.64, p = 2.2 × 10^− 5).

Sporadic forms of chronic nonbacterial osteomyelitis (CNO) demonstrate significant clinical heterogeneity between cohorts; from unifocal, non-recurrent disease to recurrent multifocal disease and disease associated with extraosseous inflammatory manifestations similar to synovitis acne hyperostosis osteitis (SAPHO) syndrome [3]. This clinical heterogeneity may reflect a similar genetic heterogeneity. Assmann et al. demonstrated that FBLIM1 variants do not appear to play a significant role in the pathogenesis of SAPHO syndrome in a European population which also included a small number of patients with CNO [4]; disease heterogeneity may explain the lack of association in this cohort .

In order to ascertain the frequency of variants in FBLIM1 in an Irish cohort of patients with CNO compared to the gnomAD non-Finnish European (gnomAD NFE) population, we have recruited 43 Irish children and adolescents with CNO currently attending paediatric rheumatology services. Ethical approval for this study was obtained from Children’s Health Ireland (CHI) at Crumlin (GEN/572/17) and CHI at Temple St (17.075). All participants met the Bristol criteria for diagnosis of CNO [5] and all were ethnically Irish. Whole exome sequencing was performed using Agilent SureSelect XT Human All Exon V6 kits and Illumina HiSeq 3000 with 150 bp paired-end reads. Reads were aligned to the hg19 reference genome using BWA software [6], duplicates removed using Picard tools and GATK software [7] used to realign indels and call variants. The resulting VCF files were annotated using wAnnovar. Rarer variants with a gnomAD NFE minor allele frequency (MAF) </= 0.05, were hard filtered for mapping quality (MQ > 40) and depth of coverage (QD > 2). A MAF of < 0.05 was selected in order to include previously published candidate variants. Statistical analysis was performed in RStudio (version 1.1.456) using Fisher exact test.

In conclusion, variants in FBLIM1 do not occur at a significantly higher prevalence than expected in the Irish paediatric population with CNO compared to gnomAD non-Finnish European allele frequencies. This does not exclude a role for FBLIM1 variants in the pathogenesis of CNO in certain populations but may suggest genetic differences related to ethnicity or clinical phenotype.